Fishing may be cruel even if you throw your catch back in the water, study finds

Pallets of fish are auctioned at Grimsby Fish Market on October 8, 2018
Credit: Dan Kitwood/Getty Images

Fishing may be cruel even if the fish are thrown back in the water, because they subsequently struggle to feed, according to a new study.

“Catch-and-release” policies have become the norm on many British rivers and lakes in recent years, considered a more human method and vital for conserving stocks.

But scientists now believe that hooking fish such as salmon and trout injures their mouths so that they become less able to suck in prey.

In the first study of its kind, researchers monitored 20 shiner perch caught from the wild in Canada.

Half had been hooked and half caught in a net.

When they were observed using high-speed cameras in a controlled environment, those that had been hooked fed significantly less well.

The scientists at University of California Riverside believe this is because the hole caused by the hook disrupts the suction system, which works similar to how humans suck fluids through as straw.

"As we predicted, the fish with the mouth injuries exhibited a reduction in the speed at which they were able to draw prey into their mouths," said Professor Tim Higham, who led the research.

"This was the case even though we used barbless hooks, which are less damaging than barbed hooks.

"Although we don't yet know how or if this reduction in feeding performance would affect fitness and survivability in nature, we can say that fishing-induced injuries impact the fish's ability to feed while the mouth is healing.

"This study emphasises that catch-and-release is not as simple as removing the hook and all being well, but rather is a complex process that should be studied in more detail."

However, a spokesman for the Angling Trust said: "The report clearly states that further research is required to assess whether or not there is any impact on fish populations as a result of catch and release angling, and studies would also be required on other species.

"Anglers takes great care of the fish they catch and have the biggest stake in thriving populations."

The new research is published in the Journal of Experimental Biology.

License this content