Apps to Improve Your Swing, Lift or Stride

Photo
Hudl Technique is an app that can help you analyze your form during a variety of activities.Credit Hudl Techniques

Phys Ed
Phys Ed

Gretchen Reynolds on the science of fitness.


DESCRIPTION
Wired Well

A special report on personal technology for health, family and fitness.

My husband and my iPhone did not agree about my running form. My husband, eyeing me critically as I ran back and forth in our backyard while he filmed me, told me that I needed to keep my head up and stop flailing my arms like Jerry Lewis in “The Nutty Professor.”

My new iPhone app told me that my running form was “superb.”

This disagreement tells you a great deal about the state of today’s most ambitious smartphone coaching apps, especially since one of those assessments was more accurate than the other, and it was not the one on my phone.

Many of us who participate in sports worry about our form. Good form is desirable, since it’s generally accepted that someone with good form, which is also known as good technique, is likely to perform better at his or her chosen sport and be less prone to injury.

But improving your form isn’t easy. Well-heeled athletes often employ a retinue of coaches and biomechanics consultants to regularly critique and fine-tune their form.

Most of us don’t have such resources and, in the past, generally relied on advice from training partners or spouses. More recently, many of us have turned to simple smartphone apps that provide recorded videos or animations showing us what the app’s developers consider to be good form for our sport, whether that sport happens to be tennis, golf, baseball, weight training, basketball, soccer, swimming, running or virtually any other activity.

But now a new generation of apps are going a step farther and providing a personalized assessment of form, together with suggestions for how to better it. These apps, with names like RunForm, BarSense, and Hudl Technique, generally require you to film yourself while you serve, squat, swing, throw, lift, run or otherwise work out.

You then upload that video to the app, and it allows you to view yourself in super slow motion, frame by frame, with accompanying commentary; overlay your swing or serve above that of a professional athlete performing the same move; or have the app use complicated geometry and algorithms to draw lines and circles across your body, assessing how you move, compared to an ideal version of that movement.

Essentially, it compares your golf swing, tennis serve or stride with a presumably perfect one and tells you how you’ve strayed from that model.

In general, these apps base their portrayals of good form on what the developers personally consider to be established coaching practices in the sport in question.

BarSense, for instance, an app aimed at weight trainers, mixes “judgment, experience, studies and just plain old physics” in its assessments of how users should be lifting and squatting, said Martin Drashkov, a software engineer and weight trainer who developed the app. (It is currently available only for Android phones.)

Similarly, the RunForm app was developed based on “hours of studying running technique,” according to its website. The developers then determined idealized “ratios and spaces among different parts of the body and the surface you are running on,” which, if adhered to, should yield better, faster strides.

In my case, RunForm, which is in beta release at the moment, drew a red bubble around my foot on one frame of my video and informed me that I land near the front of my foot, which earned me five stars from the app.

“First point of contact when landing should be your midfoot or forefoot,” the accompanying text informed me.

My stride length was a bit less laudatory, the app felt, bordering on overstriding. “Avoid landing with your ankle in front of your knee,” it wrote.

But, over all, the app felt that my form was unimpeachable.

Unfortunately, from a scientific standpoint, the perfect form for almost any sporting technique remains elusive.

“The ideal biomechanics of a variety of human movements is a holy grail that may never be obtained,” said Justin Keogh, a professor of exercise sciences at Bond University in Australia, who has extensively studied and written about skills learning and biomechanics in golf and other sports.

The problem with establishing one best way to move, Dr. Keogh said, is that if you look at successful professionals, many of them have very idiosyncratic techniques.

In golf, for instance, he said, “the most important aspect of biomechanics is that the club head must make contact with the ball in the exact way the player wishes contact to occur.” Backswing, downswing and club head speed all must be in service of creating that perfect, desired meeting of club and ball, he said.

But if you analyze professional golfers “whose ball-striking statistics can be very similar,” he said, “they have quite different swing techniques.” Similarly, anyone watching the recent baseball World Series or New York City Marathon could have noted subtle variations in how the best hitters stood and swung and the fastest racers strode.

So for most activities, there is no single, quantifiable “best” form, Dr. Keogh said, or every top performer would employ it.

On the other hand, many sports can be done quite badly, and these apps may be able to save us from “very big errors” in form, said Stuart Phillips, a professor of kinesiology at McMaster University in Canada, who frequently studies weight training and other forms of exercise. That makes them potentially of benefit for people trying out a new sport.

However, it is likely that electronic coaching will never be as potent as the flesh-and-blood version. According to Dr. Phillips, the psychology of skills acquisition suggests that “people learn through imitation of behaviors modeled by coaches or trainers and corrective feedback.”

We respond best to repeated — and hands-on — suggestions and tweaks from people, not machines.

“The available evidence suggests that lasting corrections via video feedback would be hard to make,” Dr. Phillips concluded.

So if you are convinced that you need to alter your sports technique, you might want to consult a knowledgeable coach, trainer or even spouse, instead of using an app. For the sake of harmony, however, I would advise forbidding any mentions of Jerry Lewis from the outset.

Related:


For more fitness, food and wellness news, follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or sign up for our newsletter.